|
After trying to resist the fervor surrounding Dan
Brown's novel the Da Vinci Code, I finally succumbed and
read the book after reading an article in a popular magazine that
revealed that Christians who read the novel were questioning their
faith and many non believers dismissed Christianity after reading
it. This certainly got my attention. Released in March 2003, The
Da Vinci Code has sold more than 4.5 million copies, The
acclaim surrounding the book led ABC to air a primetime special
entitled Jesus, Mary and Da Vinci: Exploring Controversial Theories
About Religious Figures and the Holy Grail. Furthermore, Hollywood
is preparing to make a movie out of the book to cash in on its popularity.
Why is this book so popular? Conspiracy theories have been popular
ever since the death of Christ, yet why are people, especially Christians
surrendering to such ideas?
In the current postmodern culture truth is a forgone
ideal. Historical fact might as well be fiction. Many modern readers
read with very little discernment and can not give a coherent critique
of current cultural ideas. In his novel Brown weaves together a
fascinating mix of conspiracies, mystery and romance, and a cheap
but thrilling story line thrown together in what seems to be the
perfect combination for the modern reader. In his novel, Brown compiles
many of the old heresies and conspiracy theories surrounding historic
Christianity. He even goes so far as to say most of what we know
of Christianity is false. The immense popularity of the novel along
with the growing murmur concerning the claims of the book, indicate
that many are buying into this brew of conspiracy theory, romance
novel and pseudo-scholarship.
A critical inspection of the book, its claims, and
the discussion it has raised are most definitely in order for those
who wish to engage the culture. Many popular reviews have lauded
Brown for giving a historically accurate version of Christian history
in the form of a novel. Two recent New York Times Book Reviews said
that "the Da Vinci Code is absorbing -- perfect for
history buffs (New York Times Book Review Fall 2003)" and "readers
have finally found a book that combines historic fact with a contemporary
story line (New York Times Book Review Fall 2003)." Even Brown
claims in the introduction to the novel that "all descriptions
of documents and secret rituals are accurate (Brown, Dan The Da
Vinci Code., Acknowledgements)." Brown then opens his book
with a page titled "FACT (Ibid., 2)." He then goes on
to describe the two main organizations in his book, the Priory of
Sion, a secret society charged with guarding the secrets of the
church, and The Vatical Prelature know as Opus Dei, a Catholic Sect.
Brown's book even contains footnotes and source materials similar
to books about history. With traits like these, one must wonder
what kind of novel Brown is attempting to put forth. If his work
were one of a scholarly nature, an opening like this would certainly
bring about the needed and compulsory scholarly criticism of fellow
intellectuals.
Brown's combination of fiction and fact, if there
is such a thing is precisely what gives the novel its irresistible
appeal. Readers are drawn into the book by its comic book fights
and chases, mystery novel plot, and romance book relationships,
find themselves absorbing historical "facts" that Brown
recounts throughout the book. The main way He disseminates these
facts is through his assembled cast of experts who reveal the secrets
of the church that have been hidden for so long. Dr. Richard Langdon
is professor of religious symbology at Harvard University. Brown's
other expert, Sir Leigh Teabing, is an expert in religious history
from Oxford. Throughout his work, Brown quotes these men as experts
on religious and historical facts. Some notable quotes come from
chapter 55 where the secret is revealed to Sophie Nevue, the beautiful
heroine who learns the true nature of the church and its conspiratorial
history from Langdon and Teabing. At the outset of the discussion
Teabing informs Sophie that "The Bible is a product of man.
Not of God
The bible has evolved through countless translations,
additions, and revisions. History has never had a definitive version
of the book (Ibid., 231)." It is revealed that Christianity
was compiled by men, namely Constantine, "Constantine fused
pagan symbols, dates, and rituals into the growing Christian tradition,
he created a hybrid religion that was acceptable to all parties
(Ibid, 232). To establish Christ's divinity, "Constantine financed
a new bible which emphasized the divinity of Christ and destroyed
earlier gospels which spoke of Christ's human traits (Ibid., 234).
To culminate his presentation, Teabing states that "almost
everything our fathers taught us about Christ was false (Ibid.,
235)." It is in this manner that Langdon and Teabing dismiss
much of historical Christianity as improvised and false.
Many of the heresies addressed in the book are nothing
new. They are simply reincarnations of heresies originating from
the time of the Gnostics. As Christian Scholar James Hitchcook notes,
"The Gnostics did not accept the Incarnation of Jesus and treated
doctrinal orthodoxy as being too literal-minded. The gospels were
not to be taken at face value but as stories with hidden symbolic
meanings (www.beliefnet.com
December 30, 2003)." Brown regurgitates many of the Gnostic
heresies and adds to them dubious doctrines such as goddess worship,
and higher criticism of scriptural interpretation, which continue
on into baseless theories on everything from church tradition to
architecture to the heads of a secret society. Some of the dogmas
and theories that Brown advances are:
- Early Christianity entailed "the cult of the Great Mother"
- Mary Magdalene represented the feminine cult and the Holy
Grail of traditional lore (One of Brown's main claims is that
the secret of the church contained in the Holy Grail is the
Fact that Mary was Jesus' wife and a symbol of the feminine
goddess in the Christian Church)
- She was also Jesus' wife and the mother of his children
- Magdalene's womb, carrying Jesus offspring, was the legendary
Holy Grail (as seen in Da Vinci's encoded paining, The Last
Supper)
- Jesus was not seen as divine (God) by His followers until
Emperor Constantine declared him so for his own purposes
- The Nicean Council of the 3rd Century was Constantine's power
grab and the relationship of Magdalene as paramour of Christ
was quashed there
- "Mary Magdalene's remains and the secret documents that
tell the real story were found on the Temple Mount when Jerusalem
was conquered in the First Crusade."
- Brown sees a connection between the Nag Hammadi documents
(a.k.a., Gnostic Gospels) discovered in 1945 and this storyline
- The "truth" about Christ and Mary Magdalene has
been kept alive by a secret society named the Priory of Sion
that was lead by great minds like Da Vinci
While Brown claims that this information is historical
and accurate, cataloguing his scholarly infractions will likely
exhaust the casual reader who is not necessarily reading for scholarly
accuracy. However, the more serious reader must wonder at Brown's
"scholarship" when he gets the date of the discovery of
the Dead Sea Scrolls incorrect (discovered in 1947 not in the 1950's
as Brown claims). The heresies that Brown advances are nothing new
and have been long-rebuffed by both theologians and historians in
a thorough manner. Many of the other theories that he advances can
only be considered flashy at best, and all baseless.
With this in mind, why have so many people read the
book as a novel and then regarded it as historically informative?
The Da Vinci Code takes esoteric criticisms of Christianity
and conspiracy theories mainstream. One scholar noted in a recent
article: "By manipulating his audience through the conventions
of romance-writing, Brown invites readers to identify with his smart,
glamorous characters who've seen through the impostures of the clerics
who hide the 'truth' about Jesus and his wife. Blasphemy is delivered
in a soft voice with a knowing chuckle: '[E]very faith in the world
is based on fabrication (Sandra Misel Crisis Magazine Dec. 2003)."
While the novel was an interesting read, one should
not take any information in the book as historical fact, or even
as a smidgen of a fact. Brown has written a novel filled with conspiracy
theories and nothing else. However, the novel has done something
very effective for our culture. It reveals that our culture, including
many Christians have a fascination with Jesus and Christianity rather
than a knowledge of Christianity. Let me explain what I mean by
this. As I stated in my opening, I have seen many instances where
Christians are questioning their faith and those in the secular
world are dismissing Christianity as a bunch of conspiracy theories
after reading the novel. The popularity of the book along with the
miniseries concerning the book, display's our culture's continuing,
albeit often misguided, fascination with Jesus.
As Christians, moments like these are opportune times
to engage the culture in an informed manner and explain what we
believe about our savior and our faith. Sadly, many Christians are
in no position to do this because they have no idea about the history
behind their faith and the rationale for their beliefs. Unfortunately
even when confronted with theories that are clearly absurd and baseless,
many Christians do not have an answer to give. Why are Christians
so quick to read books such as The Purpose Driven Life, but
can not explain how the canonization of the Bible occurred or how
central the divinity of Christ is to our faith? If we cannot answer
the central questions concerning our faith, what good is it? We
are told to be wise as serpents (Matt. 10:16) and to always be ready
to give an answer to anyone who asks (1 Pet. 3:15). The Christian
faith is a historical faith that has documented evidence and a history
of scholarship that attests to its validity. While one might be
quick to say that the job of proving these issues should be left
to Christian scholars, that is precisely where modern Christians
and the modern church have gone wrong. We have been quick to establish
programs, conferences, and retreats that emphasize the health and
wealth gospel. In the meantime, we have forgotten or simply refused
to teach ourselves and our children the essential foundations of
the faith; the faith that is very inheritance given to us and our
children. If we cannot defend the historical, rational foundations
of our faith, how do we expect to live our faith, let alone share
our faith with an unbelieving and critical culture?
I have my criticisms of the Da Vinci Code, the hype surrounding
it, and the fantastical nature of the TV special. However, the continuing
popularity of the book and the issues it bring up, while often misguided
and incorrect, serve as an opening for Christians to follow our
Lord's command and engage the culture. We need to be prepared and
ready to engage our culture in our neighborhoods, schools, and place
of work-talking about the real Jesus. Let this remind us that we
always need to be ready to give an answer.
A List of Books and resources that debunk the Da
Vinci Code and deal with heresies contained within the book.
1. Evidence
that Demands a Verdict by: Josh McDowell
2. Encyclopedia
of Bible Difficulties: by Gleason L. Archer
3. The
Case for Christ: by Lee Strobel
4. Crosswalk.com
review of Da Vinci Code
5. Focus
on the Family review of Da Vinci Code
|